Navigating Non-Competition and Non-Solicitation Agreements in Massachusetts

Restrictive covenants, particularly non-competition and non-solicitation agreements, are used to protect intellectual property, client relationships, and workforce stability. As judicial and regulatory scrutiny intensifies, businesses must carefully structure restrictive covenants to effectively protect enterprise value, retain talent, and manage legal risk. In Massachusetts, these tools operate within a highly structured and evolving legal framework that requires a nuanced approach.

Understanding Restrictive Covenants

Restrictive covenants function as legal risk management tools, limiting a party’s ability to engage in certain activities. The focus of this article is on these restrictions after an employment relationship ends. Their primary purpose is to prevent unfair competition and protect legitimate business assets such as trade secrets, confidential information, and customer relationships.

These agreements take several forms, each serving a distinct function:

Common Types of Restrictive Covenants
Common Types What They Do
Non-Compete What They DoRestricts post-employment competition
Non-Solicitation What They DoRestricts outreach to and poaching of clients or employees
Non-Servicing What They DoRestricts accepting business from clients, even without solicitation
Non-Disclosure What They DoKeeps sensitive information confidential
Non-Interference What They DoPrevents disruption of business relationships
Invention Assignment What They DoSecures company ownership of employee-created IP

Non-competes in particular are facing growing scrutiny nationwide. A growing number of states restrict or ban them outright. At the federal level, the FTC’s 2024 nationwide non-compete ban was set aside in court and formally abandoned in September 2025, but the agency continues to bring case-by-case enforcement actions against overbroad non-competes. This shifting landscape has forced employers to think critically about when these agreements are worth the legal risk.

Massachusetts’ Legal Framework: The MNAA and Common Law

Massachusetts permits non-competes but subjects them to strict statutory requirements for enforceability under the Massachusetts Noncompetition Agreement Act (MNAA), which applies to agreements entered into on or after October 1, 2018 (earlier agreements remain governed by common law). The MNAA defines a non-competition agreement as one that arises from an existing or anticipated employment relationship, and restricts an employee or expected employee (including independent contractors) from engaging in competitive activities after that relationship ends. The definition expressly includes forfeiture-for-competition agreements, that is, agreements that cause an employee to forfeit a payment or benefit as a consequence of engaging in competition. Non-solicitation agreements (covering employees, customers, clients, and vendors), non-servicing agreements (prohibiting accepting business from customers of the employer), non-disclosure agreements, invention assignment agreements, garden leave clauses, forfeiture agreements (which impose financial consequences on departure regardless of whether the employee competes), and agreements not to reapply for employment are explicitly excluded from the statute, as are non-competes made in connection with the sale of a business (discussed below), non-competes outside an employment relationship, and non-competes made in connection with separation from employment if the employee is expressly given seven business days to rescind the agreement.

This distinction has led many Massachusetts employers to rely more heavily on non-solicitation, non-servicing, and confidentiality agreements as lower-risk alternatives to traditional non-competes. For many businesses, especially those concerned primarily with protecting client relationships rather than preventing competition outright, non-solicitation or non-servicing agreements offer a more practical solution. Notably, the recent case of Miele v. Foundation Medicine, Inc., 496 Mass. 171, 260 N.E.3d 294 (2025), held that a forfeiture clause triggered by breach of an employee non-solicitation agreement is not a “forfeiture for competition agreement” subject to the MNAA.

Regardless of whether the MNAA applies, Massachusetts courts still apply a common-law reasonableness standard to all restrictive covenants. Courts take a fact-specific approach, asking whether the restriction is not broader than necessary to protect a legitimate business interest (protection from ordinary competition alone is not enough) and evaluating duration, geographic scope, and scope of activities, as well as overall fairness to the restricted party.

MNAA: Key Requirements for Employers

The MNAA imposes detailed requirements on employment-related non-compete agreements, and failure to comply with any one of them can render the agreement unenforceable. First, non-competes must meet procedural requirements. They must be in writing, signed by both parties, and must expressly state that the employee has the right to consult with counsel prior to signing. Employers must also provide advance notice: for new hires, the agreement must be provided by the earlier of a formal offer of employment or 10 business days before employment begins, and for existing employees, at least 10 business days before the agreement becomes effective.

Second, non-competes must be supported by adequate consideration. Every non-compete, whether signed at hire or later, requires either a garden leave clause or “other mutually agreed-upon consideration” specified in the agreement; employment alone is not enough. A garden leave clause must provide payment, pro rata over the entire restricted period, of at least 50% of the employee’s highest annualized base salary within the two years before termination, and the employer may not unilaterally stop those payments unless the employee breaches. Non-competes signed by existing employees must also be supported by “fair and reasonable” consideration independent of continued employment (for example, a bonus, raise, equity grant, or promotion, although the required quantum to reach the “fair and reasonable” standard remains unclear).

Third, the agreement must be substantively reasonable. The restricted period cannot exceed 12 months, or two years if the employee breached a fiduciary duty or unlawfully took the employer’s property. A geographic restriction is presumptively reasonable if limited to areas where the employee provided services or had a material presence or influence during the last two years of employment, and restricted activities are presumptively reasonable if limited to the specific types of services the employee provided during that period.

The MNAA also reflects a clear policy choice to protect certain categories of workers and preserve employee mobility. The statute references employees, but includes consultants and independent contractors. Additionally, the MNAA makes non-competes unenforceable against employees classified as non-exempt under the Fair Labor Standards Act, students in internships or other short-term employment while enrolled in school, and employees age 18 or younger, and separate statutes and professional rules bar non-competes in certain professions (including physicians, nurses, and lawyers). Further, non-competes are unenforceable if an employee is terminated without cause or laid off, reinforcing the principle that employees should be free to seek new opportunities when separation is not voluntary.

The statute also addresses enforcement. A court may, in its discretion, reform or revise a non-compete to render it valid and enforceable. A choice-of-law clause that would avoid the MNAA is unenforceable if the employee is, and for at least 30 days before leaving was, a Massachusetts resident or employed in Massachusetts. And any action relating to an employee non-compete must be brought in the county where the employee resides or, if the parties agree, in Suffolk County, where the Superior Court or its Business Litigation Session has exclusive jurisdiction.

Non-Compete and Non-Solicitation Requirements
Agreement Notice Consideration Duration Scope
Non-Compete NoticeNew hires: earlier of formal offer or 10 business days before start date; existing employees: 10 business days before effective date ConsiderationGarden leave or other mutually agreed-upon consideration specified in agreement (employment alone is not enough) DurationMaximum of 12 months (up to two years for breach of fiduciary duty or unlawful taking of property) ScopePresumptively reasonable if limited to areas where employee worked or had influence, and to services employee provided, in last two years
Non-Solicitation NoticeNo statutory notice requirement ConsiderationAdequate consideration (employment is generally sufficient) DurationTypically six months to two years in practice ScopeReasonable geographic areas and activities

The M&A Exception

Restrictive covenants arising from the sale of a business, substantially all of its assets, or an ownership interest in it are also exempt from the MNAA’s stringent requirements, and courts are more willing to enforce these covenants to protect the buyer’s legitimate business interests. Non-competes in the sale context often have longer durations (in practice, commonly three-five years or longer) and broader geographic scope, reflecting the scale of the business being transferred.

There are some requirements for the exemption to the MNAA to attach: the restricted party must be a significant owner, member, or partner in the business entity who will receive significant consideration or benefit from the sale. Such non-competes are typically a separate document from the purchase and sale agreement, and their governing law is generally set by the agreement’s choice-of-law clause; because sale-of-business covenants fall outside the MNAA, the Act’s limit on choice-of-law clauses does not apply to them. However, note that Delaware’s Court of Chancery has increasingly refused to enforce or “blue-pencil” overbroad restrictive covenants, including some sale-of-business covenants.

Non-solicitation agreements in a sale-of-business context prevent a seller from taking customers or employees. Similarly to non-competes, non-solicitation agreements arising from the sale of a business offer greater flexibility and broader enforcement than non-solicitation agreements in an employment context. Courts have traditionally been willing to enforce these agreements for extended periods (in practice, often two-five years) to protect a buyer’s investment, and are more deferential to a buyer’s legitimate business interest in preserving the customer and employee base, although the Delaware Court of Chancery has recently struck down overbroad employee non-solicits, including in the sale context.

Consideration Requirements

What qualifies as “other mutually agreed-upon consideration” or, in the case of covenants entered into after the employment has commenced, “fair and reasonable consideration” under the MNAA remains an evolving area of law. Case law is still developing, and there are few clear guidelines. However, a few principles are beginning to take shape. First, the consideration should be specific, non-illusory, and clearly defined in the agreement. Employers should also consider the timing: whether the consideration is provided at the outset of the relationship, during the engagement, after it ends, or over the course of the restricted period. This may affect the perceived adequacy of the consideration.

Second, value matters. To reduce the risk that a noncompete is found unenforceable under the MNAA, the consideration should be more than nominal. A federal district court in Massachusetts held, at the preliminary injunction stage, that a stock option grant can satisfy both the MNAA’s requirement for “other mutually agreed-upon consideration” and its “fair and reasonable” consideration requirement. See Cynosure LLC v. Reveal Lasers LLC, 2022 WL 18033055 (D. Mass. Nov. 9, 2022). While the case is helpful in validating the basic shape of what the necessary consideration should look like, there are still no bright lines in the case law concerning what amount of consideration is required.

Restrictions on Consultants

Consultants often fall within the scope of the MNAA, creating tension in worker classification. Noncompete restrictions signal a level of control that is at odds with independent contractor status. Under Massachusetts law, a worker is presumed to be an employee unless the employer can show that the individual is free from control and direction in connection with performing the service, the service is performed outside the usual course of the employer’s business, and the individual is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, profession, or business of the same nature as the service performed.

Against this backdrop, imposing noncompete restrictions on consultants requires careful consideration. In most industries, independent contractors are not accustomed to post-engagement limitations that restrict their ability to work, and such constraints may undermine the argument that they operate an independent business. Much depends on the nature of the consultant relationship: restrictions may appear more indicative of control where a consultant works exclusively for one company or has transitioned from employee to consultant status, whereas project-based consultants serving multiple clients across industries are less likely to be viewed as controlled or meaningfully restricted in their independent trade.

Takeaways for Businesses

Ultimately, enforcement in Massachusetts is grounded in a fact-specific reasonableness analysis that balances the employer’s need for protection against the employee’s ability to earn a livelihood. Employment-related non-competes are subject to heightened scrutiny, and courts are willing to invalidate agreements that are overly broad or fail to comply with statutory requirements. Covenants arising from business sales receive more deferential treatment, reflecting the commercial realities of those transactions.

For business leaders, the implications are both legal and strategic. Non-compete and non-solicitation agreements remain powerful tools, but only when used correctly.

  • Selective use: Reserve them for roles involving sensitive information or key relationships.
  • Consider alternatives: Non-solicitation and confidentiality agreements may achieve similar goals with lower legal risk.
  • Treat procedural compliance as non-negotiable: Courts will refuse to enforce non-competes that miss the MNAA’s formal requirements, such as timing, notice, signature, and consideration.
  • Tailor agreements carefully: Overreach can render an agreement unenforceable.
  • Exercise caution with consultants: Restrictions may undermine independent contractor status and increase misclassification risk.
  • Anticipate termination scenarios: Non-competes are unenforceable against employees who are terminated without cause or laid off, but the MNAA provides an avenue for an employee to agree to a non-compete in a separation agreement.

Related Content